Need clarification on my license

I need correct clarification on what I can do with my license.

My situation:
+ I have an vBSEO license purchased a couple of years ago.
+ The support for this license expired last year.
+ The site that the license is associated with is no longer online.

I sent a "question" to vBSEO support, as I can't open a case since my license is expired, asking to associate my license with my new site.

I received a response saying, "Your vBSEO license is expired. Licenses cannot be transferred to a new domain or to a new owner unless renewed".

Please note: I am not selling it. I only want to put the license on another site of mine. There is no transfer.

I reviewed the license agreement, and it seems clear that I should be able to use the license on my new site.

Quotes from the vBSEO license agreement:
+"All upgrades provided by Crawlability during the period of registration are free. In the event that an annual license expires prior to renewal, the software will remain functional, but access to further up is an additional fee for access to upgrades. Since access to upgrades expire only, the vBSEO license is referred to as a lifetime license".
+ "Crawlability Inc. allows vBSEO customers to update their forum URL, or to change from one URL to another, provided the new location is "owned by the same customer", and is NOT being transferred to another party for sale, or for any other purpose".

When your license are expired you are not eligible for vBSEO Priority Support Ticket System. License transfers to third party or a new domain are same in this instance. Your vBSEO License should be active. Otherwise as i mentioned you are not eligible for Priority Support Ticket system. Please check License Transfer Policy at Transfer Policy: Buying or Selling a vBSEO License

SPECIAL RESTRICTIONS FOR VBSEO DOMAIN CHANGES

• Customers are permitted to change their vBSEO license to a new domain.
• However, this can be done only 1 time within a 90 DAY period.
• The vBSEO license must be UN-EXPIRED.

Ok, thanks for pointing that out.

So, I may renew my license ($35 current cost), and then I can transfer to my new site. Is this correct?

Correct.

Thanks for your help guys. I'm all set now.